The League Double Header
We are going to try something a little different this time seeing as how,
oddly, two Justice League movies were released on the same day. Perhaps it made
sense for a simultaneous release since one was released
ubiquitously via iTunes only (for the next two weeks at least) and the other
was released in sort of the opposite way, in a single brick and mortar chain
without promotion as a "stealth release." Maybe the logic was that
the two were not cannibalizing each other's sales since they were targeting
different distribution streams or demographics. Well, jokes on them because I
got both! On to the reviews.
Let’s just say, live action quagmire aside, it’s a good time to be a fan of
DC movies. In fact, both movies were enjoyable, with their own shining points. Rather
than declaring one the victor, I will lay out a few notes for each. In the
end both deserve their place in the solid middle of the impressive pack of DC
animated films.
-Tone-
JLA Adventures: Trapped in Time - Light, a la JLU season 3 with goofier
humor but still legit action. Not what I want every time, but a nice change up
in the animated movie formula. Focus on the younger heroes, but not at the
expense of the grown-ups.
Justice League: War - Going for an Avengersy tone and probably more broadly
appealing than some previous Justice League movies. Adding a mix of quipy humor
and action with touches of more graphic violence. This reminds me of the
Superman/Batman animated movies, but is more satisfying than either. Wall to
wall action with highlights for each League member.
-Originality-
JLA Adventures: Trapped in Time - Although inspired by Secret Origins of
the Super Friends, less rehash than one might expect.
Justice League: War - Fairly straight up adaptation of a fairly mediocre
story. Better in motion than on the page. Some plot changes, the biggest of
which being the addition of Shazam which I do think worked better for the
movie.
-Characters-
JLA Adventures: Trapped in Time - League lineup: Superman, Batman &
Robin, Wonder Woman, Flash, Aquaman, and Cyborg. Where's Green Lantern? I was
worried about the inclusion of Legion members Karate Kid and Dawnstar, but they
were one of the movie's strengths - though other Legionnaire cameos would have
been a treat. Classic Legion of Doomer's Lex Luthor, Solomon Grundy, Toyman, Captain
Cold, Cheetah, Bizarro, Black Manta, and Gorilla Grodd were fine. Fine without
Scarecrow, Riddler, Sinestro. Giganta, or Brainiac. Only gripe is if you add Cyborg to the League, there should be a new counterpart in the Legion.
Justice League: War - League lineup: Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Flash,
Cyborg Shazam Green Lantern. Where's Aquaman? But like I said, it worked without
him. Villain: Darkseid. And as in the comic, he was not developed very well as
a character beyond being a big physical threat.
-Designs and Animation-
JLA Adventures: Trapped in Time - Given the nature of the release I was
expecting a low quality production reminiscent of an animated Happy Meal
commercial tie-in. This actually looked pretty nice. The quality may not have been up to
the level of other DC movies or even Young Justice, but in my opinion it looked
better than any of the Justice League or JLU episodes.
Justice League: War - Very nicely animated. Perhaps the palate was a bit
dark and gritty, similar to The Flashpoint Paradox, but it worked better in
that movie.
-Story-
JLA Adventures: Trapped in Time - Although there are some serious plot
holes, there are also a fair share of clever ideas that sort of make
sense if you don't overthink.
Justice League: War - Story?
-Cliffhanger-
JLA Adventures: Trapped in Time- Reminded me of the "Ape-raham
Lincoln" ending of Tim Burton's Planet of the Apes, but better.
Justice League: War - Only good if you are familiar with the Justice
League: Throne of Atlantis comic arc. If so, very tantalizing. If not, pretty
lackluster. You might as well just have placed text on the screen saying,
"The Justice League will return in Throne of Atlantis." In fact, they
may have been better.
-Title Nonsense-
JLA Adventures: Trapped in Time - No one actually got trapped anywhere. My cheesy alternative would be Peril of the Time Trapper.
Justice League: War - No war was officially declared. My copyright infringing title would be Justice League: Assemble.
Read on to see the new rankings